The Association between Depression and Suicidal Ideation A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Research Article | DOI: https://doi.org/10.31579/2637-8892/145

The Association between Depression and Suicidal Ideation A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

  • Kaleab Tesfaye Tegegne 1*
  • Eleni Tesfaye Tegegne 2
  • Mekibib Kassa Tessema 3
  • Wosenyeleh Semeon Bagajjo 4
  • Muse Rike 5
  • Alelign Tadele Abebe 6
  • Berhanu Bifato 1

1 Department of public health, Hawassa College of health science, hawassa, Ethiopia.
2 College of medicine and health science, school of nursing, university of gondar, gondar, Ethiopia.
3 Leishmania research and treatment center, university of gondar, gondar, Ethiopia.
4 Dean of Hawassa College of health science, hawassa, Ethiopia.
5 Research and publication directorate, Hawassa College of health science, hawassa, Ethiopia. 
6 Department of medical laboratory technology, Hawassa College of health science, hawassa, Ethiopia.

*Corresponding Author: Kaleab Tesfaye Tegegne, Department of public health, Hawassa College of health science, hawassa, Ethiopia.

Citation: Kaleab Tesfaye Tegegne, Eleni Tesfaye Tegegne, Mekibib Kassa Tessema, Wosenyeleh Semeon Bagajjo, Muse Rike and Alelign Tadele Abebe, Berhanu Bifato (2022) The Association between Depression and Suicidal Ideation A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J. Psychology and Mental Health Care, 6(1): DOI: 10.31579/2637-8892/145

Copyright: © 2022, Kaleab Tesfaye Tegegne, This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Received: 23 September 2021 | Accepted: 12 November 2021 | Published: 03 January 2022

Keywords: depression, suicidal ideation, ethiopia

Abstract

The purpose of this meta-analysis was to assess the association between Depression and suicidal ideation. We use data from six studies to do a meta-analysis. We applied the random-effects analytic model and calculated a pooled odds ratio. 

The combined effect size showed that odds of suicidal ideation among people with Depression is 4.88 times higher than those peoples without Depression (ORMH 4.88 95%CI 2.04, 11.72) Test for overall effect: Z = 3.55 (P = 0.0004) Heterogeneity: Tau² = 1.11; Chi² = 100.97, df = 5 (P < 0.00001); I² = 95%. The magnitude of suicidal ideation among people with Depression is 46.39% (528) and peoples without Depression is 17.79 % (315) from the total, 39.13 % (1138) is depressed and 60.86% (1779) not depressed. The overall proportion of Suicidal Ideation among the included studies is 28.98 % (843). The total number of study subjects included in our systematic review and meta-analysis is 2908.

Introduction

The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders defines suicidal ideation as a thinking about, making plans for suicide and self-destructive act with a clear expectation of death that is non-fatal [1]. The magnitude of suicide indicates as it is a serious public health problem in the world [2]. It affects more than 50 million people in the world [3]. The worldwide prevalence  of suicide is estimated to raise to 2.4% by 2020 year, and the rate of death due to suicide will be one person every 20 s [4]. It is the second leading cause of death among adolescents and young adults [5-6]. Suicidal acts result from a combination of biological, psychological, sociological, cultural and environmental factors [7].

Depression is the top risk factor and risk factors for suicidal ideation can be divided into 3 categories: psychiatric disorders, life events, and family history [8]. The most frequently reported factors correlated with suicidal behavior are being male, psychological distress [9], depression [10], dissatisfaction with academic performance, feeling neglected by parents [11-12], substance abuse, psychiatric disorders [13], drug use [14], depressive symptoms [15], first year and pre-clinical phase, homesick [16], alteration in thyroid, and prolactin hormone [17].

The loss of loved one by suicide and emotional turmoil related to bereavement also linked with increase in suicidal behavior [18]. There is also a strong positive correlation of suicide in those who are young age, male and a higher level of education [19]. However, there are limited data specifically on the association between Depression and suicide ideation.

Therefore, this study aimed to assess the association between Depression and suicidal ideation. This study would help as an input of information for health providers /psychiatrists on the relationship between depression and suicidal ideation and leads to plan suicide prevention strategies 

Materials and methods

Data

Electronic databases were searched .on reference manager software and quality assessments of the included studies were performed by assessing the risk of bias. A meta-analysis was applied to test the association between Depression and suicidal ideation. Words used to search literatures are, 'factors associated with suicidal ideation and suicidal ideation.

Study selection

Figure 1 shows the selection process of the articles searched. The initial search on reference manager software results in 89 and after duplicates removed 47 records remain and 14 studies assess for eligibility and finally 6 studies included in our systematic review and meta-analysis 

Figure 1. Study flow diagram

Measures

Suicidal ideation was the outcome variable depression was the exposure. The two variables measured in deferent way in different studies included in our systematic review and met analysis 

Analysis

By design, this study is secondary data analysis. Using Review Manager Version 5.3 software and Meta Essential software. We determined combined effect size and associated 95% confidence intervals to describe the relationship between Depression and Suicidal ideation. We calculated combined effect size across the studies using the Mantel-Haenszel (MH) statistic (the DerSimonian-Laird method or random effect model). 

We applied the random effects analytic model to account for inter survey variation and to provide a more conservative effect than a fixed model would have provided. The I 2 statistics were used to assess the variability among the included studies and above 50% was considered as significant.

Results

The characteristics of included studies according to sample size. Depression and Suicidal Ideation.

Table 1. Characteristics of the included studies

The magnitude of suicidal ideation among   people with Depression is 46.39% (528) and peoples without Depression is 17.79 %( 315) from the total, 39.13 %( 1138) is depressed and 60.86% (1779)  not depressed. The overall proportion of Suicidal Ideation among the included studies is 28.98 %( 843). The total number of study subjects included in our systematic review and meta-analysis is 2908.

Meta-analysis

Figure 2, Forest plot for the association between Depression and suicidal ideation

The combined effect size showed that odds of suicidal ideation among people with Depression is 4.88 times higher than those peoples without Depression (ORMH 4.88 95%CI 2.04, 11.72)  Test for overall effect: Z = 3.55 (P = 0.0004) Heterogeneity: Tau² = 1.11; Chi² = 100.97, df = 5 (P < 0 xss=removed>

Assessment of publication bias 

Figure 3. Funnel plot for the association between Depression and suicidal ideation
Table 2

As funnel plot showed there is no publication bias Egger Regression p value =- 0.205 Begg & Mazumdar p value = 0.851.

Source of heterogeneity 

Figure 4. Moderator analysis for the association between Depression and suicidal ideation
Table 3

As sample size increase the effect size decrease (B=0.00 p Value =0.004), so the source of heterogeneity is sample size difference of the included studies .

Discussion

This study is similar with previous studies in USA (20) ,Colombia, (21), Brazil (22), China  (10)  Nepal (11), Washington (23), Canada,(24), Bosnia and Herzegovina (25), Poland (26), Brazil (27), Malaysia (28), South Africa (29), Nigeria(30), Eriteria [8], in India (31), Ethiopia (32-35), Addis Ababa Ethiopia [36]. This may be due to high depressive symptoms that are related to suicidal risk and thoughts. A Depression that affects everyday activities, social interactions, and low self-esteem can cause increased suicidal thoughts. Many of this previous studies explained that the presence of depression is highly associated with suicidal ideation. It also indicated that the decreased level of serotonin neurotransmitter in the brain of a depressed individual was found to be associated with increased suicidal behavior [37].

The possible explanation may also be due to a direct effect of depression which makes individuals to feel hopeless, isolated and worthless [17]. The other possible explanation might be due to high levels of stress associated with adjusting to a new social environment and could be due to the effect of high dose of alcohol consumption [8]. This systematic review and meta-analysis is inconsistence with previous study [38]. The reason for the difference between our findings and this study may be the difference in sample size, study population and study participants characteristic. This study indicated that depressed persons have higher risk of suicidal ideation than no depressed persons and health provider should give focus or priority to identify depressed people as well as to assess risk of suicide in depressed people.

Conclusion

This study showed that peoples with Depression are more likely to have suicidal ideation than people without Depression.

Data Availability

All data are included in the paper.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.

Authors' Contributions

  • Kaleab Tesfaye Tegegne, Eleni Tesfaye Tegegne and Mekibib Kassa Tessema were responsible for conceptualization, project administration, software, supervision, and development of the original drafting of the manuscript. 
  • Kaleab Tesfaye Tegegne, Eleni Tesfaye Tegegne , Wosenyeleh Semeon Bagajjo, and Mekibib Kassa Tessema , Muse Rike   , Alelign Tadele Abebe , Berhanu Bifato 1were participated in quality assessment of articles, methodology, validation, and screening of research papers
  • All authors contributed with data analysis, critically revised the paper, and agreed to be accountable for their contribution.

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank all the primary authors of the included articles.

Declaration

Ethics approval and consent to participate

Not applicable.

Competing of interest 

The authors have declared that there is no competing interest.

Consent for publication 

Not applicable.

Funding 

Not any funding received for this work.

References

Dear Editorial Team, Clinical Medical Reviews and Reports. My experience with the journal was highly positive. The peer-review process was rigorous, constructive, and completed in a timely manner. The reviewers provided valuable comments that helped improve the quality and clarity of our manuscript. The editorial office was professional, responsive, and supportive throughout all stages of the publication process. Communication was clear and efficient, and any questions were addressed promptly. Overall, I found the journal to maintain high scientific standards and an excellent publication workflow. I would be pleased to consider submitting future work to this journal. Best wishes from, Elena Popa.

img

Dr Elena Popa

It was my pleasure to submit my testimonial concerning the Reviewer Board of our Scientific Journal “Brain and Neurological Disorders”. The Reviewers focused on some modifications and their contribution was helpful. The ladies of our Editorial Office were also supported my efforts. It was my honor to have such a co-operation and I am looking forward for more collaboration.

img

Dr Nikolaos Andreas Chrysanthakopoulos

Dear Grace Pierce, Editorial Coordinator of Journal of Clinical Research and Reports, Thank you for the speedy and efficient peer review process. I appreciate the fact that your peer reviewers do not take months to respond like with some other journals. I would also like to thank the editorial office for responding quickly to my questions. It is an excellent journal. I plan to submit more manuscripts in the future. Best wishes from, Robert W. McGee

img

Robert W McGee

Dear Grace Pierce, Editorial Coordinator of Journal of Clinical Research and Reports, Working with you and your team on our recent publication in JCRR has been a truly wonderful and enjoyable experience. The responses were prompt, and the reviewers were patient, constructive, and highly professional. One reviewer in particular gave me the feeling that a professor was carefully reading and commenting on my coursework, which was deeply touching. The entire process was straightforward and hassle‑free, with no tedious online forms to complete. I highly recommend this journal. Best wishes from, DR Aibing Rao, Head of R&D

img

Aibing Rao

I Appreciate the Opportunity to Share my Experience with the Journal of Clinical Research and Reports. The peer review process was timely and constructive, and the feedback provided helped improve the quality of our manuscript. The editorial office was professional, responsive, and supportive throughout the process, ensuring smooth communication and efficient handling of the submission. Overall, it was a positive experience collaborating with your team.

img

Kashani Mehdi

Dear Mercy Grace, Editorial Coordinator of Obstetrics Gynecology and Reproductive Sciences, We would like to express our gratitude for your help at all stages of publishing and editing the article. The editors of the magazine answer all the necessary questions and help at every stage. We will definitely continue to cooperate and publish other works in the Obstetrics Gynecology and Reproductive Sciences! Best wishes from, Alla Konstantinovna Politova,

img

Alla Konstantinovna Politova