HIV and Suicide Attempt in the Municipality of Ibagué, Colombia, During the Years 2020-2021

Review Article | DOI: https://doi.org/10.31579/2690-4861/916

HIV and Suicide Attempt in the Municipality of Ibagué, Colombia, During the Years 2020-2021

  • Stephanie Orozco Castillo *
  • Jordi Blach

Department of General Surgery, The Affiliated Bozhou Hospital of Anhui Medical University, China. 

*Corresponding Author: Stephanie Orozco Castillo, Department of General Surgery, The Affiliated Bozhou Hospital of Anhui Medical University, China.

Citation: Stephanie Orozco Castillo, Jordi Blach, (2025), HIV and Suicide Attempt in the Municipality of Ibagué, Colombia, During the Years 2020-2021, International Journal of Clinical Case Reports and Reviews, 29(5); DOI:10.31579/2690-4861/916

Copyright: © 2025, Stephanie Orozco Castillo. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Received: 16 July 2025 | Accepted: 14 August 2025 | Published: 18 September 2025

Keywords: mental health; human immunodeficiency virus; performance; suicidal behavior; Sivigila

Abstract

The present study analyzes the relationship between suicide attempt and HIV diagnosis in the municipality of Ibague, Colombia during the years 2020 - 2021. The study has an observational cut (data obtained from the notification forms of the Institute of Public Health Surveillance of Colombia), transversal, comparative and relationship between two events. It is observed that during the year 2020 there were 1106 suicide attempts and 361 HIV diagnoses; for the year 2021 a frequency of 933 suicide attempts, and 335 HIV diagnoses. A sociodemographic characterization of the analyzed populations is also presented. 

Results: In 2020 with a total of N: 1106 (54.23%), while for the year 2021 N: 929 (45.57%), of which 4 (0.20%) are living with AIDS. Now, in the statistical analysis it is observed: χ²= 2383.83675, P= 0; r= -1; r^2= 1; ODS RATIO VALUE= 0.00165975. 

Conclusions: There does not seem to be a strong relationship between the risk of committing suicide and having HIV; It is observed that the risk of suicide attempt in the city of Ibague is 0.0001%; With the value of χ², the Null Hypothesis is rejected; With the value of P it is determined that the relationship between the variables is null. 

1.Introduction

This is a study that seeks to identify the occurrence of suicidal attempt behavior in patients diagnosed with Human Immunodeficiency Virus -HIV in the municipality of Ibagué, Colombia, during the years 2020 - 2021.

Currently, these two variables—suicide attempt and HIV diagnosis—are of particular interest to the Colombian Public Health Surveillance System (sivigila). Self-harm behavior has been measured since 2016, and "since then, a gradual increase in the national incidence rate has been observed" (sivigila; 2020). Figure 1.

Behavior of the suicide attempt incidence rate by epidemiological week, Colombia, 2018 to 2020

Note: In 2020, 26,202 cases of attempted suicide were reported to Sivigila. The suicide attempt rate per 100,000 inhabitants during 2020 showed a decrease compared to 2018 and 2019. In recent years, an upward trend has been observed, with a higher incidence in women. The rate per 100,000 in 2020 began an upward trend at the beginning of the year, the same trend seen in 2018 and 2019. During week 13, there is a decrease. However, during the three years mentioned, peaks of increase and decrease can be seen. Taken from the National Institute of Health, Colombia. Suicide Attempt Event Report 2020. Available at: https://www.ins.gov.co/buscador-eventos/Informesdeevento/INTENTO DE SUCIDIO_2020.pdf 

According to statistical data presented by Sivigila (2020), within the 37 departments that make up Colombian territory, 43% had rates higher than the national rate, that is, 52.0 per 100,000 inhabitants. Among the highest rates is the department of Tolima.On the other hand, national HIV diagnosis monitoring has seen a 14.6% increase compared to 2019-2020. The High-Cost Accounts (CAC) report highlights a growing trend. In 2019, Tolima had a rate of 223 people living with HIV, while in 2020, the rate was 241.Now, for suicidal behavior to occur, the presence of different risk factors is estimated, such as genetic-biological factors, social-demographic factors, family and childhood characteristics, and personality traits and cognitive styles (R, 2019), with HIV being a risk factor for the occurrence of self-harm behavior (Palacios; Rueda; Valderrama 2006).

Justification 

The relationship between HIV and suicide carries culturally constructed social stigmas that require a counterintuitive approach based on the data available in the health sector. This situation constitutes a process in which society categorizes people based on traits that are rejected or undervalued and that have been established as negative categories. These categories are constituted as defects, flaws, or disadvantages that are inconsistent with the stereotypes of the different population and age groups prevalent in HIV.The stigmas associated with HIV and suicide reveal the negative side of a person's perspective on normality (defined by the dominant majority group in society). In this sense, it is pertinent to clarify that discrimination is the action through which certain attributes (genotypic and social) of people are devalued, directly or indirectly justifying the exercise of various types of violence against those who possess them. This is complemented by the understanding that discrimination has a genealogy in each society, as well as particular discursive forms and sociohistorical behaviors that belong to its past and are transmitted from generation to generation. (Margulis and Urresti, 1998, p. 292; Martin-Pérez, 2021).In addition to the physical and emotional dependence that increases when both physical and psychological characteristics require greater levels of care, it generates responses that often express a type of discrimination: abandonment and self-neglect, which results in suicidal thoughts or behaviors. One phase of this process would be the acquisition of beliefs about what it means to be a person with HIV in the society in which they live, and a second phase would be learning the consequences of living with HIV, including suicidal behavior.The counterintuitive approach based on epidemiological data allows us to take into account the relationships of the HIV positive person with both the informal and formal communities to which they belong, which are crucial. Stigmatization, in this case related to HIV and suicide, allows us to identify common life situations that lead to a joint classification, which in turn can organize assumptions about human nature around them: with the intersectionality of ethnicity, age group, socioeconomic status, and gender, which complements the complexity reduction achieved by HIV data and its correlations and possible causalities with suicide. Based on the above, the question arises : is there a relationship between the increase in HIV diagnoses and the increase in suicidal behavior in the municipality of Ibagué, Tolima, during the years 2020-2021? It should be noted that in Colombia and Tolima, there are no studies or analyses of this type that seek to relate two variables. Similarly, the notification forms for both events do not address these variables; the suicide attempt notification form explores chronic illness, while for the HIV notification form, the clinical information does not address psychological history or the current course of suicidal ideation.

Objective System 

  1. General Objective 

To evaluate the relationship between suicidal behavior and attempted suicide in HIV patients in the municipality of Ibagué Tolima during the years 2020-2021.

  1. Specific Objective 

A.      Profile sociodemographic variables of people diagnosed with HIV.

B.       To analyze the sociodemographic variables of people with suicide attempts in the municipality of Ibagué Tolima during the years 2020-2021.

  1. Theoretical Conceptual Framework

The process of social identity construction, which emerges in situations of social interaction, has, in HIV, a source of stigmatization against which society establishes the means to categorize people. The social environment establishes categories of people who can be found within it. Social exchange then makes it likely that when interacting with a stranger, our first appearances allow us to predict which category they fall into and what their attributes are—that is, their social identity.To understand the bio-psycho-social impact of HIV/AIDS on the deterioration of social identity, it is necessary to understand the origins of stigma. Martin-Pérez (2021) indicates that it is produced by primary reactions such as fear of the unknown, contagion/transmission, and the constant search for transmission of the virus. Similarly, the same author relates stigma to the lack of or erroneous information about AIDS, HIV, and the discriminatory relationship with other previously stigmatized groups such as the LGBTI+ community, sex workers, and drug users. On the other hand, Parker et al. (2012) propose four categories of stigma that are immersed in society: sexuality, gender, race, and social class; thus, people with HIV are associated with already stigmatized groups, which increases the individual's vulnerability.Thus, stigma can be considered a social and multidimensional phenomenon that affects people with HIV not only in their physical health but also their mental health. In this area, manifestations such as loss of self-esteem, poor self-concept, feelings of vulnerability, loss of control over future events, loss of security or self-confidence, feelings of worthlessness and helplessness, loss of social, family and marital role, deterioration of social, family and partner relationships, difficulties in carrying out work or occupational activities, difficulties in carrying out leisure and recreational activities, financial worries, changes in life perspective, guilt, irritability, depressive symptoms, and anxiety and/or stress are found (Palacios; Rueda; Valderrama 2006). Furthermore, one of the turning points for suicidal ideation and behavior is associated with personal history, which accompanies and sustains the amplification of stereotypes.In the class on stigma and discrimination taught in the Master's Degree in Human Immunodeficiency at the Rey Juan Carlos University of Spain by Professor Martin-Pérez (2021), he relates studies in which People with HIV have felt excluded or discriminated against in the following way: Myanmar 11% of People with HIV have been excluded from family events; in China 79% of people expressed fear of being the center of gossip; in the United Kingdom 22% reported physical aggression, on the other hand, in Ecuador 12% reported that they were expelled from educational institutions due to their HIV status Palacios et al (2006) like Lopera (2010) conclude that in Colombia more quantitative research is needed around discrimination and stigma in People with HIV. Ramos-Jaraba in her study with transgender women (2021) shows how 15.8% of People with HIV avoid health services, and 45

2.Results

In 2020, 44 new cases of HIV infection were reported in the municipality of Ibagué; while in 2021, there were 335. Regarding age, the average age for HIV diagnosis was 35 years, with a minimum of 3 years and a maximum of 85 years between 2020 and 2021. Regarding sex, it is observed that HIV is diagnosed more frequently in males; during 2020, 35 men were identified, while in 2021, 260 were diagnosed. Regarding women, 9 women were notified, compared to 2021, where an increase of 75 was observed.

  1. sociodemographic variables HIV
SOCIODEMOGRAPHIC VARIABLES OF PEOPLE WITH HIV2020%2021%
Reporting frequency4411.60%33588.40%
AGE GROUPadulthood287.39%16744.06%
youth112.90%13134.56%
old age51.32%277.12%
adolescence0082.11%
early childhood0020.53%
SEXF92.37%7519.79%
M359.23%26068.60%
NATIONALITYColombia379.76%32585.75%
Cuba20.53%00
No data41.06%00
Venezuela10.26%92.37%
Guatemala00.00%10.26%
CLINICAL STADIUMdead10.26%61.58%
AIDS41.06%348.97%
HIV3910.29%29577.84%
CAUSE OF DEATHB230 Acute infection syndrome10.26%00
NOT APPLICABLE4311.35%00
A419 Sepsis0010.26%
B227 HIV disease0010.26%
B24X HIV disease not otherwise specified0051.32%
J158 Other pneumonias0010.26%
J159 Bacterial Pneumonia0010.26%
J189- Unspecified pneumonia0010.26%
J960 Acute respiratory failure0010.26%
NOT APPLICABLE0032485.49%

Table 4: Sociodemographic variables People with HIV.

Although this proposal focuses on the municipality of Ibagué, the notification form identifies the nationality of people living with HIV. In 2020, there were 37 new cases of HIV in people of Colombian nationality, 2 of Cuban origin, and 5 of Venezuelan origin. During 2021, there were 325 new cases of HIV in Colombian nationality, 1 new case of HIV in Guatemala, and 9 new cases of Venezuelan nationality.Now, it is important to identify the clinical stage of people with HIV at the time of notification. Here, it can be seen that, for 2020, the stages were: Death: 1; AIDS: 4; HIV: 39. For 2021, the stages were: Death: 6; AIDS: 34; HIV: 295.Finally, it was identified that in 2020 the leading cause of death among people living with HIV was acute infection syndrome; in 2021, the leading causes of death were HIV disease not otherwise specified, acute respiratory failure, and respiratory illnesses such as pneumonia.

  1. Sociodemographic variables Suicidal behavior

Table 5: Sociodemographic variables Suicide Attempt

Suicide attempts in Ibagué occurred in 2020, with 1,106 attempts reportedwhile in 2021, 933 cases were recorded. Regarding the age group most frequently involved in this behavior, in 2020 it was youth aged 17 to 28, as in 2021, with 372 cases reported. Children are the group that reports the fewest cases; however, they represent a significant number for this population. Within the sex variable, women are the ones who attempt suicide most frequently; in 2020, there were 652 attempts, and in 2021, there were 528 suicide attempts. Regarding marital status , those who attempted suicide most frequently in both years were single people, followed by those in common-law marriages. Since Ibagué is a multicultural city, it is observed that in addition to Colombians, there are people of other nationalities who have resorted to suicide attempts, with Colombians being the most frequent, Venezuelans in second place, and the Republic of the Congo in third.Now, regarding the factors that trigger a suicide attempt, the notification form lists 10 factors: relationship conflicts, legal problems, chronic illness (painful or disabling), suicide of a family member or friend, financial problems, history of violence, death of a family member, work problems, school problems, and family problems.For this analysis, the variable chronic illness was considered, as was the presence of another factor along with chronic illness. Thus, in 2020, it was found that 37 people diagnosed with chronic illness attempted suicide; 33 people with chronic illness attempted suicide in 2021. Secondly, it was found that chronic illness, coupled with financial and relationship problems, led to eight people attempting suicide in 2020. In 2021, the number of people who attempted suicide was chronic illness, relationship problems, the death of a family member, school problems, and legal problems. This suggests that suicidal behavior has multiple causes.

  1. Frequency of HIV diagnosis in suicidal behavior

To determine the relationship, the following data were taken into account:

Hypothesis: Suicide attempt variable is associated with HIV.

Null hypothesis: Suicide attempt variable is not associated with HIV.

HIV: is a nominal qualitative variable.

Suicide Attempt: qualitative variable payroll.

Sample: non-probabilistic for convenience.

It is important to mention that the statistically significant value for all the results that will be presented below is P value <0>

For the suicide attempt variable, between the years 2020-2021, 2,039 people attempted suicide. In 2020 with a total of N: 1,106 ( 54.23%) , while for the year 2021 N: 929 ( 45.57%) , of which 4 ( 0.20%) are People with HIV.

FREQUENCY OF SUICIDE ATTEMPTS
YEARN%
2020Suicide attempt110654.23%
2021Suicide attempt92945.57%
Suicide attempt in people with HIV40.20%
TOTAL2039100.00%

Table 6: Frequency of Suicide Attempt in People with HIV

However, during 2020 there were no suicide attempts in people living with HIV, however, in 2021 there were 4 cases of suicide attempts in people living with HIV. These data may hide underreporting, since the design of the instruments from which information on suicide attempts is collected includes chronic diseases, but it is not specified which ones. The statistical analyses show: χ² = 2383.83675, P = 0; r = -1; r^2 = 1; SDG RATIO VALUE = 0.00165975.

DESCRIPTION OF VARIABLES
SUICIDE ATTEMPTNO SUICIDE ATTEMPTSDG VALUE RATIOχ²Prr^2
People with HIV43750.001659752383.836750-11
People who do not live with the virus.20350

Table 7 : Description of variables

Taking into account these results, it can be said that:

  • There does not appear to be a strong relationship between suicide risk and HIV status.
  • It is observed that the risk of attempted suicide in the city of Ibagué is 0.0001%.
  • It would be important to examine the mental health care variable in future studies. This would help determine whether there are protective factors.
  • The null hypothesis is rejected with a χ² value. There are discrepancies between the frequencies of the variables. The actual value is less than 5. The result is unreliable.
  • The P value determines that the relationship between the variables is null.
  • Now, the value of r indicates that with perfect inverse correlation, it shows that although suicide attempts are increasing in the city of Ibagué, it is not related to the increase in HIV diagnoses.

3.Conclusions.

With this study, the following conclusions can be reached :

Microinteractionism contributes to defining a conceptual framework for analyzing HIV stigma and suicidal behavior; stigma as a damaged image; and HIV stigma as linked to the categories of prejudice, discrimination, and abandonment. Here, it is important to expand the research in the Colombian context, emphasizing the relationship with health services.The revelation and redefinition of the category of interaction as a subsystem of the social system, without denying the existence of other subsystems and, above all, their belonging to a larger order, allows us to complement the available quantitative data series on HIV and suicidal behavior with an approach to the social determination of health and illness.Social interaction and changes in society will impose norms, bringing to light differences derived from the status, sex, nationality, and skin color of the interactants. This will be related to the entire "porous" situation of variable meanings that are attempted to be monitored. In this sense, we seek to control the effects of our actions on stigma and suicidal behavior.In today's society, there is a stigma toward people living with HIV, which in practice leads to the emergence of various types of discrimination. One of the goals of the World Health Organization's 90-90-90 strategy is to reduce this stigma. In Colombia, work continues toward this objective.Advances in health technologies, both in diagnosis and treatment, have allowed for a new understanding of HIV as a chronic degenerative disease. This has led to improved quality of life and life expectancy. However, in Colombia, mental health professionals need to be trained in HIV (currently, training in this area is exclusively for physicians) in order to create and strengthen HIV prevention and treatment adherence programs.

References

Dear Editorial Team, Clinical Medical Reviews and Reports. My experience with the journal was highly positive. The peer-review process was rigorous, constructive, and completed in a timely manner. The reviewers provided valuable comments that helped improve the quality and clarity of our manuscript. The editorial office was professional, responsive, and supportive throughout all stages of the publication process. Communication was clear and efficient, and any questions were addressed promptly. Overall, I found the journal to maintain high scientific standards and an excellent publication workflow. I would be pleased to consider submitting future work to this journal. Best wishes from, Elena Popa.

img

Dr Elena Popa

It was my pleasure to submit my testimonial concerning the Reviewer Board of our Scientific Journal “Brain and Neurological Disorders”. The Reviewers focused on some modifications and their contribution was helpful. The ladies of our Editorial Office were also supported my efforts. It was my honor to have such a co-operation and I am looking forward for more collaboration.

img

Dr Nikolaos Andreas Chrysanthakopoulos

Dear Grace Pierce, Editorial Coordinator of Journal of Clinical Research and Reports, Thank you for the speedy and efficient peer review process. I appreciate the fact that your peer reviewers do not take months to respond like with some other journals. I would also like to thank the editorial office for responding quickly to my questions. It is an excellent journal. I plan to submit more manuscripts in the future. Best wishes from, Robert W. McGee

img

Robert W McGee

Dear Grace Pierce, Editorial Coordinator of Journal of Clinical Research and Reports, Working with you and your team on our recent publication in JCRR has been a truly wonderful and enjoyable experience. The responses were prompt, and the reviewers were patient, constructive, and highly professional. One reviewer in particular gave me the feeling that a professor was carefully reading and commenting on my coursework, which was deeply touching. The entire process was straightforward and hassle‑free, with no tedious online forms to complete. I highly recommend this journal. Best wishes from, DR Aibing Rao, Head of R&D

img

Aibing Rao

I Appreciate the Opportunity to Share my Experience with the Journal of Clinical Research and Reports. The peer review process was timely and constructive, and the feedback provided helped improve the quality of our manuscript. The editorial office was professional, responsive, and supportive throughout the process, ensuring smooth communication and efficient handling of the submission. Overall, it was a positive experience collaborating with your team.

img

Kashani Mehdi

Dear Mercy Grace, Editorial Coordinator of Obstetrics Gynecology and Reproductive Sciences, We would like to express our gratitude for your help at all stages of publishing and editing the article. The editors of the magazine answer all the necessary questions and help at every stage. We will definitely continue to cooperate and publish other works in the Obstetrics Gynecology and Reproductive Sciences! Best wishes from, Alla Konstantinovna Politova,

img

Alla Konstantinovna Politova