info@auctorespublishing.com
+1-(302)-520-2644
+1-(302)-520-2644

Alternative Behaviour Management Techniques for Children with Intellectual Disability – A Review

  1. Home
  2. Journals
  3. Clinical Medical Reviews and Reports
  4. Archives
Submit Guidelines

Review Article | DOI: https://doi.org/10.31579/2690-8794/246

Alternative Behaviour Management Techniques for Children with Intellectual Disability – A Review

  • Nirmala Chandrasekaran 1*
  • SriLakshmi. L 2
  • Yamini Michelle Maran 3
  • Anil Kumar Ramachandran 4

1 Associate Professor, Department of Conservative Dentistry & Endodontics, Ragas Dental College & Hospital, The Tamil Nadu Dr.MGR Medical University, Chennai, India.

2 B.Ed. Special Education (ID), Managing Director, Lakshmi’s Lexis World, Chennai, India.

3 2nd Year MBBS Student, Sri Ramachandra Institute of Higher Education and Research, Chennai, India.

4 Principal & Head of the Department of Conservative Dentistry & Endodontics, Ragas Dental College & Hospital, The Tamil Nadu Dr.MGR Medical University, Chennai, India.

*Corresponding Author: Associate Professor, Department of Conservative Dentistry & Endodontics, Ragas Dental College & Hospital, The Tamil Nadu Dr. MGR Medical University, Chennai, India.

Citation: Nirmala Chandrasekaran, SriLakshmi. L, Yamini M. Maran, Anil K. Ramachandran, (2024), Alternative Behaviour Management Techniques for Children with Intellectual Disability – A Review, Clinical Medical Reviews and Reports, 6(10); DOI:10.31579/2690-8794/246

Copyright: © 2024, Nirmala Chandrasekaran. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Received: 15 December 2024 | Accepted: 23 December 2024 | Published: 31 December 2024

Keywords: intellectual disability; alternative behavior management; positive behavior support (pbs); mindfulness-based interventions; art therapy; animal-assisted therapy; challenging behaviours; emotional regulation; social skills; therapeutic approaches

Abstract

Children with intellectual disabilities often face challenges in managing their behavior, significantly impacting their well-being and social interactions. While traditional behavior management techniques can be effective, alternative approaches may better address the diverse needs of these children. This paper reviews alternative behavior management techniques for children with intellectual disabilities, providing definitions, benefits, and examples of each method, alongside research evidence supporting their effectiveness. The review highlights the importance of these techniques in improving behaviour, social skills, and emotional well-being, ultimately enhancing quality of life and promoting independence. Emphasis is placed on the need for further research to identify the most effective methods and expand the range of options available to parents, educators, and healthcare professionals. This work offers hope for children with intellectual disabilities and their families, presenting viable alternatives that foster greater inclusion and personal development.

Introduction

Intellectual disability (ID) is a condition that significantly affects cognitive functioning, adaptive behavior, and developmental milestones. It is characterized by limitations in intellectual abilities (e.g., reasoning, problem-solving, and learning) and difficulties in adapting to the demands of daily life. Behavioral problems such as aggression, self-injury, anxiety, and hyperactivity are common and can severely impact their quality of life and social inclusion [1-2]. Children with intellectual disabilities often face social, educational, and emotional challenges, making their care and management a multifaceted endeavour [3]. 

While traditional interventions, such as Applied Behaviour Analysis (ABA) and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), are effective in many cases, their applicability may be limited due to resource constraints, cultural differences, or the need for highly individualized care [4]. Alternative behavior management techniques have emerged as complementary or substitute approaches to address these limitations [5-6].

For centuries, society has struggled to fully integrate individuals with intellectual disabilities. Misconceptions and stigmas hindered their inclusion, and formal support systems were often inadequate. Advancements in understanding and addressing ID have led to improved interventions, though challenges remain. A critical aspect of supporting individuals with ID is managing behavioural difficulties that can arise from the condition [7].

This review explores innovative, evidence-based, and culturally adaptive methods that focus on improving behavioural outcomes for children with intellectual disabilities.

Discussion

Understanding Intellectual Disabilities

Intellectual disabilities are distinct from physical or sensory disabilities, as they specifically impact cognitive and adaptive functioning. While individuals with physical disabilities may experience motor impairments or sensory deficits, their cognitive abilities often remain intact. In contrast, ID involves significant challenges in mental processes and the ability to learn or adapt to new situations [1-2].

Key characteristics of Intellectual Disability:

  1. Cognitive Limitations: Difficulty with problem-solving, abstract thinking, and academic skills8.
  2. Adaptive Behavior Challenges: Impairments in social interactions, communication, and practical life skills [9].
  3. Developmental Delays: Delays in achieving milestones like walking, talking, or learning [10].

The severity of ID can range from mild, where individuals may achieve a degree of independence with support, to profound, where individuals require intensive care throughout life [11].

The causes of intellectual disability are diverse and can be broadly classified into:

  1. Genetic Factors: Conditions like Down syndrome, Fragile X syndrome, and Prader-Willi syndrome [12].
  2. Prenatal Influences: Maternal infections, substance abuse, or nutritional deficiencies during pregnancy affecting fetal brain development [13].
  3. Perinatal Factors: Birth complications such as oxygen deprivation or premature delivery leading to brain damage [14].
  4. Postnatal Causes: Head injuries, infections like meningitis, or exposure to toxins impairing intellectual development [14].
  5. Neurobiological Mechanisms: Structural and functional brain abnormalities, including altered neural connectivity, disruptions in synaptic functioning, or deficits in cognition and adaptive behavior. Genetic mutations impair the formation of proteins essential for neuronal communication, leading to intellectual impairments [15].

Prevalence: Intellectual disabilities affect approximately 1-3% of the global population. Both sexes and all socioeconomic groups are impacted, although certain genetic conditions (e.g., Fragile X syndrome) may show gender predispositions [16].

Detection Timeline

  1. Infancy: Severe forms of ID may be detected shortly after birth due to physical anomalies or significant developmental delays [17].
  2. Early Childhood: Most cases are diagnosed during the preschool years when children fail to meet cognitive or developmental milestones [18].
  3. School Age: Milder forms of ID may not become evident until academic or social demands increase [17].

Diagnostic Methods

  • Developmental Assessments: Tools like the Bayley Scales of Infant Development evaluate cognitive and motor milestones [19].
  • IQ Testing: Standardized tests (e.g., WISC-IV, Stanford-Binet) measure intellectual functioning [20].
  • Medical Evaluation: Genetic testing, brain imaging, and metabolic studies help identify underlying causes [21].

Normal Management Techniques

Behavioral and Educational Interventions

  1. Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA): ABA uses reinforcement strategies to teach adaptive skills and reduce problem behaviours. It is highly structured and often involves one-on-one sessions [22].
  2. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT): CBT helps children recognize and modify negative thought patterns to improve emotional regulation and behavior [23].
  3. Special Education Programs: Tailored educational plans focus on developing functional skills in a supportive learning environment [24].

Therapeutic Approaches

  1. Speech Therapy: Helps improve communication skills in children with verbal delays [25].
  2. Occupational Therapy: Aims to enhance fine motor skills and daily living activities [26].
  3. Physical Therapy: Addresses gross motor delays and coordination issues [27].

Pharmacological Management

Medications may be prescribed to address comorbid conditions such as ADHD, anxiety, or aggression28. Common examples include:

  • Stimulants for attention deficits [29].
  • Antipsychotics for severe behavioral challenges, though these can have side effects like weight gain and sedation [30].

Family and Community Support

  • Educating families about the child’s condition and their role in interventions is critical for ensuring consistency in care [31].
  • Support groups provide emotional support and practical guidance to caregivers [32].

Community-based programs can empower families with accessible resources and training to manage behavioral challenges effectively [33].

Challenges and Limitations of Traditional Management

· Accessibility Barriers

  • Traditional therapies such as Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) can be resource-intensive, requiring trained professionals, one-on-one sessions, and financial investment [34].
  • This makes them inaccessible to families in low-resource settings or regions with limited availability of specialists.

· Neglect of Cultural and Contextual Factors

  • Many traditional methods are designed without sufficient consideration for cultural diversity or family dynamics.
  • Techniques often fail to adapt to the values, traditions, and socio-economic conditions of diverse caregiving environments [35].

· Lack of Individualization

  • Traditional approaches often adopt a one-size-fits-all model, which may not address the unique needs of children with syndromic intellectual disabilities or severe impairments [36].

· Behavioral Resistance

  • Some children with intellectual disabilities are resistant to structured and rigid interventions, making traditional methods less effective [37].
  • These children may respond better to creative, flexible, or play-based interventions.

· Focus on Deficits Rather Than Strengths

  • Many traditional techniques emphasize correcting behavioral deficits rather than building on the child’s strengths.
  • There is a growing movement toward strength-based approaches that promote emotional well-being, creativity, and holistic development [38].

Emerging and Alternative Techniques

Alternative techniques aim to complement or replace traditional methods by incorporating innovative, less resource-intensive, and more culturally adaptive strategies [39].

1. Pharmacological and Hormonal Adjuncts

Pharmacological interventions are increasingly being studied as complementary therapies for behavior management in ID populations [40].

  • Oxytocin-Based Therapies: Oxytocin, a hormone linked to social bonding, has been investigated for its potential to reduce social anxiety and enhance prosocial behaviours in children with intellectual disabilities, including those with autism spectrum disorder (ASD). Studies report mixed outcomes, with early-phase trials demonstrating promising results, particularly in improving eye contact and social interactions. However, more robust, long-term studies are required [41].
  • Other Pharmacological Interventions: Medications such as risperidone and aripiprazole are commonly used to manage aggression and irritability [42]. These can be combined with behavioural therapies to enhance overall outcomes, although potential side effects, such as weight gain and sedation, must be monitored [43].

2. Technological Innovations

Technology has opened new avenues for delivering behavior management interventions, especially in settings with limited access to therapists.

  • Telemedicine:
    Telemedicine platforms facilitate remote consultations, allowing caregivers to receive professional guidance on managing behavioural issues. This approach has gained momentum, particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic, and has proven effective in providing access to underserved areas [44].
  • Digital Applications and Virtual Reality (VR): Digital tools, such as apps that track behavior patterns or VR-based simulations, are emerging as interactive ways to teach social and coping skills. VR environments can simulate real-life scenarios, helping children practice appropriate responses to various social cues in a controlled and engaging manner [45].

3. Non-Traditional Therapies

Alternative therapies emphasize creativity, play, and holistic approaches, offering a more engaging experience for children.

  • Music and Art Therapy:
    • Music Therapy: Reduces anxiety, enhances social engagement, and improves emotional regulation [46]. For example, group music sessions can encourage peer interaction in a non-verbal and low-pressure setting.
    • Art Therapy: Provides a medium for self-expression, helping children communicate emotions they may struggle to articulate verbally [47].
  • Play Therapy: Play therapy creates a safe and structured environment where children can explore and resolve conflicts. Techniques like role-playing allow children to practice social skills and develop emotional resilience [48].
  • Animal-Assisted Therapy (AAT): AAT involves interaction with animals to promote emotional and social development. Activities such as petting, walking, or playing with animals create a calming effect and foster engagement. It improves emotional regulation, reduces anxiety, and enhances social interaction49. Animal-assisted therapy can also encourage empathy and communication skills in children who struggle with these areas. Dogs, horses (equine therapy), and small animals like rabbits are commonly used for therapy sessions.
  • Mindfulness-Based Interventions: Mindfulness techniques such as meditation, breathing exercises, and guided relaxation aim to enhance emotional regulation, reduce stress, and improve focus. Mindfulness can help children with intellectual disabilities become more aware of their emotions and reactions, fostering self-regulation and reducing anxiety. It will have a positive impact on emotional well-being, with potential improvements in attention span and stress management [50].

4. Syndrome-Specific Approaches

Children with specific syndromes may require customized behavioural interventions tailored to their unique challenges.

  • Prader-Willi Syndrome (PWS): PWS is characterized by impulsivity, food-seeking behavior, and social challenges. Structured environments, consistent routines, and impulse-control strategies are essential in managing behavioural issues [51].
  • Wiedemann-Steiner Syndrome (WSS): Children with WSS often benefit from sensory integration therapies that address hypersensitivities and improve focus [52].
  • Other Syndromes: Syndromes like Fragile X and 3q29 Deletion Syndrome often require a combination of sensory-based therapies and targeted behavioural strategies [53].

5. Cultural Adaptations

Behavioral management techniques must be culturally sensitive and accessible to families across diverse socioeconomic backgrounds. Adapting interventions to align with cultural norms and family values enhances acceptance and sustainability [54]. Storytelling and culturally significant games can be incorporated into play-based therapy.

A table comparing different behavior management techniques (traditional and alternative) based on key parameters such as scope, effectiveness, and limitations.

TechniqueDescriptionTarget PopulationStrengthsLimitations
ABAApplied Behavior Analysis, structured approachAll ID levelsEvidence-based, effective for behaviorResource-intensive, less flexible
CBTCognitive restructuring therapyMild-to-moderate IDImproves cognition, addresses anxietyRequires verbal skills
Oxytocin-Based TherapyHormonal therapy for social behavioursASD, syndromic IDPromising for social impairmentsMixed results, long-term unclear
Music TherapyCreative therapy using musicAll ID levelsReduces anxiety, boosts engagementLimited data on long-term impact
Play TherapyStructured, exploratory play-based interventionYounger childrenEnhances social skills, engagingMay require customization

Challenges and Future Directions

1. Barriers to Implementation

  • Resource Constraints: Many alternative techniques require specialized tools or training, which may not be available in low-resource settings.
  • Caregiver Fatigue: The burden on caregivers to consistently apply behavioural techniques can be significant, necessitating support mechanisms.

2. Research Gaps

  • There is a lack of longitudinal studies evaluating the sustainability of alternative techniques.
  • More research is needed on the cultural adaptability of behaviour management interventions.

3. Integration into Care Models

Healthcare systems must integrate alternative techniques into existing care frameworks to improve accessibility. Multidisciplinary teams, including psychologists, occupational therapists, and educators, can collaborate to create individualized plans.

References

  1. Deshmukh DV (2016). Strategies used to modify the behaviours of children with intellectual disability. Indian Journal of Health and Wellbeing. 2016 Jul 1;7(7):753-756.
    View at Publisher | View at Google Scholar
  2. Grey IM, Hastings RP (2005). Evidence-based practices in intellectual disability and behaviour disorders. Current opinion in psychiatry. 2005 Sep 1;18(5):469-475.
    View at Publisher | View at Google Scholar
  3. Ali A, Blickwedel J, Hassiotis A (2014). Interventions for challenging behaviour in intellectual disability. Advances in psychiatric treatment. 2014 May;20(3):184-192.
    View at Publisher | View at Google Scholar
  4. Matson JL, Dixon DR, Matson ML (2005). Assessing and treating aggression in children and adolescents with developmental disabilities: a 20‐year overview. Educational Psychology. 2005 Apr 1;25(2-3):151-181.
    View at Publisher | View at Google Scholar
a